POLLS     NHL STATS     EDMONTON OILERS

TRENDING NOW


OILERS INSIDER  |  NHL  |  NEWS

The NHL explains the disputed penalty call against Elias Pettersson


PUBLICATION
Sam Jones
May 17, 2024  (1:56 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY
FOLLOW US




Elias Pettersson
Photo credit: BOB FRID-USA TODAY SPORTS

The Vancouver Canucks faced a moment of uproar when Elias Pettersson was slapped with a charging penalty, an event that led to fans expressing their displeasure in a dramatic fashion by hurling drinks onto the ice.

The scene became a focal point for controversy not just for its intensity but for the peculiar circumstances surrounding the penalty call.
At the heart of the issue was the nature of Pettersson's penalty. The forward was penalized for a maneuver that, visually, seemed more a defensive act than an aggressive charge. The official NHL rule on charging, as noted by broadcasters Elliotte Friedman and Ron MacLean, states:
"Charging (Rule 42.1): A minor or major penalty shall be imposed on a player who skates, jumps into or charges an opponent in any manner."

Despite the clarification, the decision was met with widespread criticism. The inconsistency of the game's officiating was pointed out by spectators across the hockey community, who lamented the "brutal calls and non-calls" that seemed to sway the momentum of the match.
Further complicating the discourse is the broader context of NHL refereeing throughout the series. Accusations of players from both teams embellishing plays to draw penalties and referees striving to balance infraction calls have tainted the viewing experience. Such a haphazard approach to officiating has led to a significant part of the fanbase voicing their dissatisfaction, a sentiment captured succinctly by online reactions.
As the Oilers face elimination in Game 6 on Saturday, the hope among fans and players alike is that the focus will shift back to the game itself, rather than the controversies off the puck. The prevailing sentiment is a desire for a game dictated by player skill and strategy, not the whistles of the referees.
POLL
MAY 17   |   58 ANSWERS
The NHL explains the disputed penalty call against Elias Pettersson

Were you thinking this should have been a penalty on Elias Pettersson?

Yes, it was a penalty3865.5 %
No, it wasn't a penalty1220.7 %
See Results813.8 %
LIST OF POLLS
Latest 10 stories

OILERSINSIDER.COM
COPYRIGHT @2024 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS  -  POLICIES  -  CONSENT